“We Were Liars” — A Sober Lens on Family Secrets, Dysfunction and Recovery

In this episode, host Alysse Bryson and co-host Tamar Routly join Sober Curator contributors Amy Liz Harrison and Dr. Sarah Michaud for a thoughtful, spoiler-free review of the Amazon Prime adaptation of the young adult novel “We Were Liars.” 

But this conversation is more than a show breakdown. It’s an insightful discussion about addiction, family patterns, the illusions of wealth and the excitement and meaning behind living a sober lifestyle. Whether you’re considering recovery, searching for community or looking for perspectives on intergenerational healing, you’ll find valuable takeaways here.

Why “We Were Liars”? Why Now? 

“We wanted to talk about this because it’s not just a show — it’s a mirror,” Bryson says. This episode investigates why “We Were Liars” resonates so strongly with people in recovery and those who want to live authentically. 

Set among a privileged, secret-ridden family on a private island, the series serves as a starting point to discuss how addiction, trauma and power can persist in the most “picture-perfect” environments. It’s an honest look at the reasons for choosing sobriety and the emotional work it takes to heal. 

The Sober Lens: Missing Out or Gaining Everything? 

From the beginning, the hosts set the tone: Sobriety isn’t about missing out; it’s about finally remembering who you are. Rather than focus solely on the series’ plot, the conversation touches on how growing up with control, secrecy and expectations affects self-worth. Recovery, they reveal, is about claiming autonomy. 

Dr. Michaud notes, “You think about money meaning freedom, but throughout the show, the real message is: money can be a prison.” The idea that privilege protects against pain is dismantled, underscoring the liberation that comes with living honestly. 

Key Takeaways and Insights 

Secrets as Prison Walls 

• The podcast highlights how the Sinclair family’s secrets echo the dual lives often led by those struggling with addiction. 

• “Everybody is dismissing their real self to present this image,” Michaud says. The emotional price of maintaining appearances is evident in both the show and in recovery. 

The Myth of Wealth 

• The hosts discuss how wealth can actually lead to emotional isolation rather than freedom. 

• “They were all bankrupt spiritually,” Routly says, pointing out the emptiness behind the perfection. 

Sobriety in Real Life and On Screen 

• The character of Carrie Sinclair, a sister with a decade of sobriety, is praised as a rare and relatable portrayal of recovery. Her struggle to access an online AA meeting is universally understood by those who have reached for support in challenging family environments. 

• Harrison shares: “For me, the moment where she finally seeks a meeting, and something interrupts it … it’s a reminder that even after years, you still have to actively fight for your sobriety.” 

Generational Dysfunction and Breaking the Cycle 

• The episode examines how silence, control and competition are passed down through generations, trapping families in cycles of pain. 

• “You turn out to be your environment,” Bryson says, sparking a conversation on the courage to start over and model something better. 

The Joy of Sobriety 

• Sobriety is framed not as loss but as empowerment, truth and lasting fulfillment. The guests share how recovery lets them live as they really are, rather than according to family histories or addiction. 

Why Are They Excited About Sobriety? 

The message is clear: Sobriety is freedom, clarity and connection — especially connection to one’s true self. For Bryson, Routly, Harrison and Michaud, living sober isn’t just abstaining from alcohol. It’s about having real fun, real joy and experiencing genuine relationships. 

This episode isn’t just for people in recovery. It’s for anyone hoping to break negative family cycles, face the truth with courage and live fully awake. 

As Bryson says: “Getting sober matters. But staying sober — that’s where the real magic, the promises, the freedom, happens.” 

Real Talk for Real People 

What sets this episode apart is its vulnerability. The hosts and guests do not shy away from old pain — and they demonstrate, with humor and candor, that recovery requires ongoing effort but brings immense value. 

If you have ever felt alone at a family gathering, wondered why you drank or dreamed of a different way to live, this episode is a source of encouragement and support. 

Final Thoughts 

Episode 27 of The Sober Curator is essential listening for anyone who wants sober inspiration and honest talk about healing. It’s an invitation to choose recovery, face family secrets and live boldly and joyfully — without substances. 

---

THE MINDFUL BINGE: We Were Liars on Amazon Prime—A Review Through the Lens of Addiction

---

THE MINDFUL BINGE at The Sober Curator is where we binge-watch and chill—mindfully. In this TV series review section, we don’t just consume shows; we explore their stories, themes, and cultural impact through a sober lens. Using our signature Sobees Scoring System, we rate each pick to help you choose your next watch with intention.

Our digital shelves are neatly organized into Drama, Dramedy, and Reality, making it easy to find your perfect series for a night in.

---

RECOVERY PODCASTLAND & NETWORK at The Sober Curator is your audio haven for all things sobriety and recovery. We’re your bee-zy sober podcast enthusiasts, curating the best shows that educate, inspire, and entertain in the alcohol-free space.

Our archives are neatly organized so you can easily explore Recovery Podcastland—featuring our favorite recovery-based podcasts from across the globe—and the TSC Podcast Network, where we share our own original shows on sober lifestyle, pop culture, travel, entertainment, and more.

Whether you’re seeking practical recovery tips, personal stories, or uplifting inspiration, this is your go-to listening guide.

---

You’ve got mail from The Sober Curator

Resources Are Available

If you or someone you know is experiencing difficulties surrounding alcoholism, addiction, or mental illness, please reach out and ask for help. People everywhere can and want to help; you just have to know where to look. And continue to look until you find what works for you. Click here for a list of regional and national resources.

Subscribe to The Sober Curator on YouTube