Gray Area, Bright Lines: Why Kelley Kitley’s Honesty Lands Where It Hurts — and Heals
“I just want to take the edge off.” It’s the whisper that pretends to be help. On a quiet out-of-town night, therapist and author Kelley Kitley felt that old whisper again — years into sobriety. The picture looked harmless enough: hotel room, kid at practice, fatigue baked into the week. Then came the honest math: half an hour of exhale in exchange for a full day of consequences — and, if history has any say, a lot more than one day. So she did what the sober old-timers teach and our egos hate: she told on herself. A group text went out. The responses flooded back. The moment passed. She drove on, blasting Jelly Roll, a small defiant anthem that said: not today.
Kitley’s story is disarmingly ordinary, which is exactly why it’s brave. The cultural script for “problem drinking” still clings to extremes — job lost, life burning, bridges ash. Gray-area drinkers rarely look like that. They look like successful graduates who “partied and blacked out” and then aced a class the next morning. They look like moms taking the edge off with nightly wine because parenting is relentless and the world keeps suggesting a glass might help. Qualifiers — I wasn’t homeless, I didn’t lose my job — become the comforting lullaby that keeps the questions at bay.
On the episode, Alysse and Kelley pull at the thread that binds those qualifiers to stigma. When people insist, “I’m not an alcoholic, I’m alcohol-free,” language can widen or close doors. Sometimes the point of a label is courage, a way to step into rooms where help lives. Sometimes the point is permission, an identity that makes change feel possible. As Kelley notes, your circle often shapes your language; the aim is to choose what protects your life. The rest is just branding.
Kitley also names the tension many clinicians feel: the traditional rule to keep personal history out of the room. She risked otherwise. Journals turned into chapters, which turned into a book she could only finish after she got sober. It wasn’t about confession as spectacle; it was about belonging. When one person says the quiet part loud, isolation breaks — and in that draft of oxygen, recovery gets practical.
Long-term sobriety, the pair agree, is less a straight line than a daily practice. Some days it hums in the background; others, it taps your shoulder and asks, Remember me? That’s when “play the tape forward” matters — a miniature time machine that fast-forwards past the first exhale to the shame spiral, the hangover, the logistics. That’s also when community becomes not just a concept but a speed dial.
And because real life never restricts itself to a single headline, the conversation widens: perimenopause rage that flashes like weather, sleep that goes missing, bodies that remember old shortcuts (restricting, overworking, over-exercising) even after we’ve retired them. The trick isn’t to outrun biology; it’s to refuse old bargains. Stack tools early. Ask for help before the cliff. Keep it boringly practical.
Perhaps the most subversive thing in the episode is the insistence that sober life is not a punishment, and it’s definitely not boring. Boring was blackout déjà vu and keys you couldn’t find because you couldn’t remember the night before. Connection, on the other hand, is vivid. When Kelley’s kids ask why mom doesn’t drink and dad can, the answer lives in behavior and outcomes, not in shame. When friends ask about labels, the response is generous: do what works, but know that language shapes pathways. And when a craving pops up uninvited, call your people, put on the song and drive. That’s not dour self-denial; that’s choosing freedom.
If you’ve ever felt stuck in the gray, consider this your nudge to turn on a brighter light. Choose the word that opens the door to the room you need. Tell on yourself early. Borrow someone else’s hope until yours clocks back in. Most of all, remember: the tape always plays past the first sip. Let it. Then choose the life you keep getting to have.
Listen to the full episode of The Sober Curator Podcast featuring Kelley Kitley wherever you get podcasts.
Find Kelley in the digital places and social spaces:
Getting sober is one thing—but staying sober? That’s where the real adventure begins.
This show is for you if you’ve ever wondered:
– Where can I find inspiring sober podcasts, apps, and creators?
– How do I give back or stay plugged into the sober community
– What are the best sober-friendly drinks and travel tips?
– Where do I find the good NA drinks that don’t taste like regret?
The Sober Curator is your go-to for sober pop culture, booze-free travel, apps, creators, and community.
We’re not here to help you get sober.
We’re here to help you live sober—and love it.
In this hilariously honest and deeply human conversation, Emmy-winning host Cat Greenleaf joins Alysse to spill all the sober tea—from peeing her pants during a double-booking with Tom Arnold and Art Alexakis, to discovering what sobriety actually looks like when you're no longer a “lone wolf.” Cat opens up about service, creativity, aging, friendship with Pee-wee Herman, crafting on cocaine, and the real emotional glow-up that happens when you stop pretending and start living. This episode is equal parts chaos, charm, confessions, and zero-proof realness.
Takeaways: Sobriety gets richer when you stop isolating and start connecting with people who speak your language.
Cat’s shift from “lone wolf” to community deepened her recovery—and her sanity.
Golden-age celebrity stories? Yes please. Especially ones involving Pee-wee Herman sending hourly birthday messages.
Creativity, addiction, and reinvention always have a wild intersection (including cocaine-fueled stenciling).
“Zero fucks given” remains a valid business plan—and a liberating way to live.
Key Timestamps:
[00:01:47] — Cat Greenleaf arrives: The sober stoop era begins.
[00:04:30] — “Sometimes I wish I’d shut the f*ck up”: Cat on oversharing in recovery.
[00:06:13] — The Tom Arnold + Art Alexakis pee-your-pants saga.
[00:11:00] — Pee-wee Herman memories: birthday calls & inappropriate Christmas cards.
[00:14:21] — Cocaine + crafting: Cat and Alysse trade hilarious addiction-era stories.
[00:17:00] — Hobby obsessions, lone-wolf recovery, and life after chaos.
[00:22:00] — The infamous dog-poop showdown on Cat’s beach.
[00:23:56] — The healing power of work, ocean singing, and coffee.
Resources & Links:
Cat Greenleaf — SoberNess Podcast Website https://www.soberness.com/
Cat on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/sobernesspodcast/
Cat on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@sobernesspodcast
Cat on Apple https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/soberness-podcast/id1768121457
TSC Resources & Links:
–Alcohol + Substance Use Disorder Guide
–Recovery Nonprofit Resource Guide
–LBGTQ+ Recovery Resource Guide
Connect with Us:
-Website: www.thesobercurator.com
-Facebook: @The Sober Curator
-Instagram: @thesobercurator
-X: @thesobercurator
-YouTube: @thesobercurator
-Pinterest: @thesobercurator
Follow & Subscribe:
If you enjoyed this episode, please consider leaving a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Your feedback helps us improve and reach more listeners.
Send Feedback:
If you have a story, feedback, or just want to connect, email us at thesobercurator@gmail.com. We’d love to hear from you!
About:
Sobriety isn’t the end of the party—it’s just the start of a better one. Hosted by Alysse Bryson, media powerhouse and sobriety’s ultimate hype woman, and joined by Sober Curator contributors, The Sober Curator Podcast* delivers bold convos, pop culture deep dives, and zero-proof living that doesn’t suck. Whether you're sober, sober-curious, or just looking for good vibes without the hangover, we’ve got you covered. Subscribe now—because getting sober matters, staying sober matters more.
*The Sober Curator Podcast is a space for open and honest conversations about sobriety, recovery, and alcohol-free living. While we celebrate all paths to a sober lifestyle, some topics discussed may be sensitive or triggering for certain listeners. This podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. If you’re in recovery or exploring sobriety, please take care while listening and seek support from trusted professionals as needed.
🔗TSC Podcast on Apple Podcasts
🔗TSC Podcast on Spotify Podcasts – 👀WATCH THE SHOW! 📺
🔗 TSC Podcast on YouTube – 👀WATCH THE SHOW! 📺
Your Go-To Guide for All Things Recovery & Sober Living
The Sober Curator’s PILLAR Content Hub is your one-stop guide for sobriety resources, addiction recovery resources, and sober living tips. From non-alcoholic drink guides to sober travel, entertainment, and lifestyle inspiration, our curated cornerstone articles are regularly updated to keep you informed, inspired, and connected. Whether you’re in recovery, sober curious, or supporting someone you love, this hub offers the sober lifestyle guide you’ve been looking for.
SOBER POP CULTURE at The Sober Curator is where mainstream trends meet the vibrant world of sobriety. We serve up a mix of movie, podcast, fashion, and book recommendations alongside alcohol-free cocktails, celebrity features, and pop culture buzz—all with a sober twist.
We’re here to shatter the “sobriety is boring” myth with a mash-up of 80s neon, 90s hip-hop edge, early 2000s bling, and today’s hottest trends. From celebrity shoutouts to red-carpet style inspo, this is where sober is as chic as it is fun. To the celebs using their platform for good—our Sober Pop Trucker hats are off to you!
Resources Are Available
If you or someone you know is experiencing difficulties surrounding alcoholism, addiction, or mental illness, please reach out and ask for help. People everywhere can and want to help; you just have to know where to look. And continue to look until you find what works for you. Click here for a list of regional and national resources.
